Secret Santa Gifts

A touch of mystery, a dash of mischief—discover petite luxuries that turn the holiday exchange into pure enchantment.

9 products
Sort

Sort

9 products

Price

The highest price is

$
$
Clear
Flavor
Clear
Dietary preferences
Clear
More Filters
Clear
Clear all
Clear all

9 products

  • exotic-truffle-collection-9-pieces exotic-truffle-collection-9-pieces
    Exotic Truffles, 9 pieces

    $25-$74BFCM 2025Dark ChocolateExclude - Marshmallow Add OnExotic chocolateHighly PerishableMilk ChocolateNational Truffle DayOakley BoutiqueSecret Santa GiftstrufflesWCDWomen Ownedzest-gift

    $38
    $38
  • caramel-marshmallows-9-pieces caramel-marshmallows-9-pieces
    Caramel Marshmallows

    $25-$74BestsellerBFCM 2025CaramelCravingsDark ChocolateExclude - Marshmallow Add OnFather's DayHighly PerishableMarshmallowOakley BoutiqueSecret Santa Giftszest-gift

    $36
    $36
  • bapchis-caramel-toffee-half-pound bapchis-caramel-toffee-half-pound
    Bapchi's Caramel Toffee

    $25-$74BestsellerBFCM 2025CaramelCravingsExclude - Marshmallow Add OnGifts for HimNutsOakley BoutiqueSaltSecret Santa GiftsToffeezest-gift

    $32
    $32
  • passionfruit-caramels-6pc passionfruit-caramels-6pc
    Passionfruit Caramels

    BFCM 2025clearanceexcludeExclude - Marshmallow Add OnGifts for BestiesHoliday 2025Holiday Promo 2025SEARCHANISE_IGNORESecret Santa GiftsShopmy-ExcludeStocking StuffersVault2026zest-gift

    $11
    $18 $11
  • naked-vanilla-marshmallows-4-pieces naked-vanilla-marshmallows-4-pieces
    Naked Vanilla Marshmallows

    $0 - $24Gluten FreeHoliday 2025Limited EditionMarshmallowNut Freeparty favorsSecret Santa GiftsShopmy-ExcludesmoresSoy freezest-gift

    $8
    $8
  • aztec-elixir-drinking-chocolate aztec-elixir-drinking-chocolate
    Aztec Drinking Chocolate

    Ancho ChilliAztecBFCM 2025ChilliChipotle ChilliCinnamonDark ChocolateDrinking ChocolateGifts for BestiesHolidayHoliday 2025Holiday 2026hot chocolateSecret Santa GiftsShopmy-ExcludeSnowboundVanillazest-gift

    $28
    $28
  • baton-du-chocolat-cookies-shortbread-covered-in-chocolate baton-du-chocolat-cookies-shortbread-covered-in-chocolate
    Bâton du Chocolat

    $25-$75BFCM 2025Classic ChristmasexcludeExclude - Marshmallow Add OnHoliday 2025SEARCHANISE_IGNORESecret Santa GiftsShopmy-ExcludeStocking StuffersVault2026zest-gift

    $18
    $30 $18
  • hot-chocolate-baton-cookies-gift-set hot-chocolate-baton-cookies-gift-set
    Dip n' Sip Gift Set

    10-30-25BFCM 2025Classic ChristmasclearanceexcludeGifts for BestiesHoliday 2025Holiday Promo 2025SEARCHANISE_IGNORESecret Santa GiftsShopmy-ExcludeTop 10 2025zest-gift

    $55
    $55
  • linnea-rainforest-palms-soy-candle linnea-rainforest-palms-soy-candle
    Rainforest Palms Linnea Candle

    BFCM 2025BYE25excludeExclude - Marshmallow Add OnHoliday 2025SEARCHANISE_IGNORESecret Santa GiftsShopmy-ExcludeStocking StuffersVault2026zest-gift

    $36
    $45 $36